Security fiasco: When politics takes precedence over security
In a situation marked by unpopular judicial reform, Benjamin Netanyahu finds himself directly accused of neglecting the terrorist threat and strengthening Hamas to the detriment of the Palestinian Authority. After decades of political domination, “Bibi” could pay the price for this colossal failure.
The deadly attack carried out by Hamas on Saturday October 7 opened a new political era in Israel. Some compare this national trauma to the September 11 attacks in the United States.
Palestinian fighters sowed terror and death for several hours in southern Israel, killing more than 1,200 people. In retaliation, Israeli strikes in the Gaza Strip have already killed more than 1,350 people, mainly civilians.
This attack aroused palpable anger in Israel. While the majority of this anger is directed at Hamas, there is also growing anger toward the government of Benjamin Netanyahu, which has failed on security issues.
Some critics say it is the worst government the country has seen and has compromised national security. The Israeli population seems divided like never before.
Benjamin Netanyahu has always been a controversial figure in Israeli politics. Implicated in corruption cases, he is suspected of wanting to become Prime Minister again to escape prosecution and influence the judicial system.
At the head of the most right-wing government in Israeli history, Benjamin Netanyahu is trying to impose an unpopular judicial reform aimed at subjecting the Supreme Court to the authority of Parliament. Massive demonstrations took place for nine months to protest against this reform.
Under the leadership of Benjamin Netanyahu, the country is deeply divided and trust in the government is plummeting. Israelis feel that they are not listened to or represented by their leaders.
The Prime Minister has shown a minimum of communication since the Hamas attack, arousing incomprehension and anger among the population. Israelis expect real leadership from their leaders during this time of crisis.
The slow military response to the Hamas attack raises many questions about the effectiveness of Israeli intelligence services. Some criticize Benjamin Netanyahu for favoring settlers by supporting controversial people within his government.
In short, this political-security fiasco highlights the deep divisions that run through Israeli society and calls into question the government’s ability to ensure national security. Benjamin Netanyahu’s failure to face the threat of Hamas could well cost him his position as political leader. In this troubled context, it is essential to regain political stability and renew dialogue with the different factions to restore confidence and face the security challenges that arise.